Ohio State Doctors in Both Veterinary and Human Medicine Give Burned Paint Horse a Second Chance with Complex Skin Grafts

YouTube Preview Image

The unlikely pairing of an equine veterinarian and a burn surgeon is providing a second chance at a normal life for a horse that was doused in flammable liquid and set on fire late last summer.

Fran Jurga bylineThe Ohio State University doctors and their teams have partnered to perform two skin graft procedures on the American Paint Horse named Northstar, who suffered severe burns to almost half of his body when the abuse occurred.

The same instruments used in a typical human burn surgery were used for the horse’s grafting procedures. The clinicians removed ultrathin sheets of skin from Northstar’s chest and expanded them with a meshing tool before placing the grafts across an enormous wound spanning the horse’s back.

When he arrived in Columbus on September 5 of last year, Northstar had exposed bone at the base of his neck as a result of the burns. Skin damage extended from his neck to the base of his tail and along both of his sides. No suspect has been identified in the case.

The doctors’ collaboration – not to mention the unusual size of the back wound – has provided a rare learning experience for both clinicians and their colleagues.

Northstar at Ohio State's vet hospital

Northstar was attacked in his field in Pennsylvania. Veterinarians and human doctors are collaborating on skin grafts to heal his wounds. (Photo courtesy of Ohio State)

“There’s been a lot of trial and error with the challenges of how to bandage him, what the most appropriate antiseptic is for cleaning the wound bed, and the biology of burned tissue in a horse,” said Samuel Hurcombe, assistant professor of veterinary clinical sciences and the leader of Northstar’s care team.

Veterinary experts got the healing off to a good start with relentless wound management, a series of smaller skin grafts and the implantation of cell cultures in the wound bed. These procedures were performed to bring top-layer skin tissue to the central area of the expansive wound bed on Northstar’s neck and shoulders, where all his skin had burned away.

To address the large wound across the horse’s back, Hurcombe consulted longtime trauma and burn surgeon Larry Jones at Ohio State’s Wexner Medical Center. The two observed one another’s surgeries and studied human- and veterinary-medicine journal articles before teaming to accelerate Northstar’s care.

Jones, associate professor of clinical surgery and director of the Burn Center at the medical center, led the two larger skin graft surgeries. Early on, he encountered a significant challenge: how deep to set the tool that would peel off the donor skin.

“We want to take the top layer of skin but we also need a portion of the second layer, the dermis,” he said. After Jones consulted with Hurcombe and the two conducted more research, “I knew I had to take a graft that’s about twice as thick as one I would take if I were operating on a human.”

The team then ran the graft through a mesher that cut holes in the graft skin and allowed for expansion of the graft to about four times its original size. “When the graft takes, the holes will fill in from skin cells growing from the edges,” Jones said.

They dressed the wounds with bandages containing medical-grade silver, which functions as an antibiotic, to speed healing of the grafts and the donor sites.

Observers during surgery for Northstar horse

Northstar's historic surgery was recorded by observers in the operating room at The Ohio State University during skin grafting process. (Ohio State photo)

At this stage of the horse’s recovery, more than half of the initial wound is healed, with the repair resulting from both the various skin grafting procedures and normal closure along the edges of the damaged skin. Northstar will likely undergo a series of additional sheet graft surgeries to completely heal the wound. Multiple grafts are often required for extensive human burn injuries, as well.

“It’s a slow process but even in the time we’ve been caring for him, he has made remarkable progress,” said Hurcombe, a specialist in equine emergency and critical care. “From a welfare standpoint, his psychology is great and after what he’s gone through, the fact that he is still so trusting of people is pretty amazing.”

While he initially appeared to be a dark horse for recovery, Northstar persevered through weeks of daily cleansing and removal of dead and infected tissue followed by the application of antiseptics, honey, aloe and silver sulfadiazine cream, a common human burn treatment, to his damaged tissue.

In yet another application of human medicine in veterinary care, the team has treated Northstar with gabapentin (sold under the brand name Neurontin), a medication used for neuropathic pain in humans, to treat the severe itching and nerve-related pain that is typical in burn patients as they recover.

Northstar, who turned seven in January, is a “young, naughty boy” and would love nothing more than to toss himself to the ground and roll on his back to scratch that persistent itch, Hurcombe said. So the horse is gently tethered to keep him standing and he wears a cradle that immobilizes his neck several hours throughout the day. He is also covered in bandages and wears what is called a full-body “sleazy” covering that is typically seen on show horses.

Ohio State Northstar horse surgery

Preparations for Northstar's surgeries (Ohio State image)

The clinicians hope that Northstar will have a complete layer of skin coverage by his eighth birthday. The road ahead is a long one, both physicians acknowledge. The location of his back wound is a tricky one to treat because even with secure bandages from his neck to his tail, the horse anatomy in the location of the burn is such that Northstar’s every movement slightly disturbs the grafted areas.

“His skin graft take is a little less than what I am used to in humans,” Jones noted. “But as Dr. Hurcombe reminds me, considering his hospital bed is in a barn, he is doing very well.

“I view Northstar in the same way as I do any of my other patients. I just want him to get better and go on and live his life as a horse.”

Northstar’s owners live in northwestern Pennsylvania, where police have investigated the burning incident as a criminal case.

“All the owners want is for him to be happy, pain-free and able to live his life with his pasture mates,” Hurcombe said. “He is bright and alert, he interacts with people and he can eat and drink and do all the things that a horse can normally do as far as function. And he has been telling us through his behaviors that he wants to live. ”

To learn more: A foundation has been established to help Northstar.

Original documentation for this article was provided by The Ohio State University.



jumping-foal-713469 by Fran Jurga
© The Jurga Report at Equisearch.com 

Be friends with Fran Jurga on Facebook.com  

Longines Luxury, French Fashion, a Royal Museum and Animal Kingdom: You think this has nothing to do with you?

Chantilly racecourse by Guillaume Cattiaux

There are racecourses, and there is Chantilly, the stunning site of yesterday's fashionable Prix de Dianes near Paris. The building in the background, once the French royal stables, is now a museum, recently refurbished by the Aga Khan, whose horses have won the Prix de Dianes seven times. Photo by Guillaume Cattiaux.

Longines…that’s French for “luxury”, right?

If you’re in the market for a Swiss timepiece (as opposed to what the rest of us wear on our wrists, called simply a “wristwatch:”), yes, the name Longines is synonymous with a luxury purchase.

And if you are a fan of horse racing or equestrian sports on television, you’ve noticed the advertisements, all cast in a dreamy blue glow, and you now know the word “Longines” is connected to luxury even if you have never held one to your wrist–or figured out that those beautiful ads had anything to with timekeeping.

YouTube Preview Image

This weekend, Longines notched the luxury level up again. It was the most elegant weekend of the year for French horse sport, the running of the Prix de Dianes at Chantilly outside Paris on Sunday. The weekend is traditionally a super-sophisticated “ladies” event.

Imagine Kentucky Oaks day with the women – all of them — dressed by couture designers.

If you connect England’s Royal Ascot Ladies’ Day with fashion, you might think the French are out to one-up the Brits. And they do it effortlessly on Prix de Diane day. Just watch:

YouTube Preview Image

But it wasn’t all about fashion this year. First, it was the grand opening of the magnificent Museum of the Horse in what was once the grandiose stables on the racecourse at Chantilly, thanks to the largesse of the gentile patron of international horse racing, the Aga Khan, shown on CNN this weekend giving Francesca Cumani a personal tour of the building that once housed 250 royal French horses and hundreds of hounds:

YouTube Preview Image

Amidst it all, Longines unveiled its new awards for women in the horse industry. They brought along Australian actor Simon Baker, star of The Mentalist, and a favorite chick-flick of mine, The Devil Wears Prada.

The awards were presented to racehorse owner Princess Zahra Aga Khan, showjumper/heiress Athina Onassis de Miranda and French model/actress/promoter of horses and famous jockey’s wife, Sophie Thalmann.

Princess Zahra Aga Khan received an award for her commitment to horsebreeding. Athina Onassis de Miranda received an award for her contribution to the development of equestrian sports in Latin America, in particular through the Athina Onassis Horse Show, held each October in Rio de Janeiro, BrazilSophie Thalmann received an award for promoting the equestrian world through arts and media.

The memory of Simon Baker in The Devil Wears Prada sent me to YouTube looking for a special scene from that movie. Meryl Streep explains why a blue sweater is not just a blue sweater, which speaks volumes about why all of us should stop what we’re doing to pay attention to Longines or Chantilly or any of this luxury business.

If you are wondering what a fashion weekend in the Parisian countryside has to do with The Jurga Report or you and your horses, there’s no better explanation that this scene from that movie:

YouTube Preview Image

Keeping that blue sweater analogy in mind, prepare yourself, because Royal Ascot opens tomorrow in England and on the program will be the feature race, the Queen Anne Stakes. Amidst the carriages and the morning coats and the top hats and the fascinators will be a horse we have all come to know and love: 2011 Kentucky Derby winner Animal Kingdom.

He has come back from two leg fractures. This will be the third continent on which he has raced — he has won in both the USA and Dubai. And when it is over, he will head to a fourth, Australia, where he will stand at stud.

Superstar Frankel ran at Royal Ascot last year, and won the same race. This year, our beloved American horse and an American jockey, Johnny Velasquez, will test the royal grass by racing past the Queen Herself.

The whole world will be watching — some on television, but a huge audience will find a legitimate (or not) livestream for their phones and tablets and laptops. The rest will watch it on YouTube when it’s over.

YouTube Preview Image

You can be sure that everyone in the Royal Enclosure at Ascot will look perfect. Longines will be there to make sure it happens on time. At some point, the dreamy blueness of the Longines commercials and the reality of Ascot on opening day may blur into one tableau of everything traditional, beautiful and yet exhilaratingly suspenseful.

The word “horse” will appear in newspapers around the world in the middle of the week. Animal Kingdom will either break hearts or become an instant legend.

And you think this has nothing to do with you?

Give yourself the luxury of watching a horse race for all time on a Tuesday morning. Clean your fingernails. Wear clean jeans. Comb your hair. You don’t need a Longines on your wrist or a dress code primer to be part of it all, because you already are.



jumping-foal-713469 by Fran Jurga
© The Jurga Report at Equisearch.com 

Be friends with Fran Jurga on Facebook.com  

Rider Input Needed for Saddle Research Project’s Online Survey

saddle research

Can you help saddle research by filling out a survey?

The Jurga Report is sharing a request from the Saddle Research Trust in Great Britain:

Equine vets at the Animal Health Trust are appealing to horse riders to help with an important research project that will assess the interaction between horse, saddle and rider. Participants simply need to complete an anonymous online questionnaire. In so doing they will be helping to protect and improve the future health, welfare and longevity of the ridden horse, researchers say.

Dr Sue Dyson, Head of Clinical Orthopaedics at the Centre for Equine Studies at the Animal Health Trust and her PhD student Line Greve, DVM, MRCVS , are conducting a detailed study to find out how the horse, rider and saddle can influence each other. They are particularly trying to understand better why a saddle may persistently slip to one side in some horses.

“Saddle slip is a problem seen in all sorts of horses and ponies and can contribute to back pain and thus impaired performance,” explains Line Greve. “Research suggests that 25% of British dressage horses have a history of back-related problems and subsequent reduced performance. Our preliminary studies involve just over 700 riders but for a more accurate picture we would like to bump this figure up to 1000 plus. We are urging all riders, whatever their level or ability, to help by completing the questionnaire.”

The online questionnaire should take no more than 15 minutes to complete and all answers remain anonymous. The questions cover saddle types, fitting, use and maintenance; rider experience, training and ‘handedness’; as well as horse type, use and any previous lameness or back-related problems.

Please follow this link to the questionnaire http://www.aht.org.uk/cms-display/premise_questionnaire.html.

The results will be presented at the ground-breaking Saddle Research Trust Conference in 2014.

Photo: In the Bag Solutions via Flickr.com



jumping-foal-713469 by Fran Jurga
© The Jurga Report at Equisearch.com 

Be friends with Fran Jurga on Facebook.com  

Five Cases of Neurotrophic Equine Herpes Virus at Ontario’s Woodbine Racetrack; One Horse Dead

The Jurga Report Quarantine Horse Health AlertThe Jurga Report shared news on Twitter last night from the Toronto Star regarding a report by Horse-Canada blogger Jennifer Morrison on a filly that was euthanized at Woodbine Racetrack in Ontario, Canada. A disease outbreak was expected. This afternoon we received an official statement from the Ontario provincial government and have reprinted it here for your use.

The Ontario Racing Commission (ORC) announced this afternoon that there have been five confirmed reports of the neurotrophic form of EHV-1 in Thoroughbreds residing in Barn 1 at Woodbine Racetrack in suburban Toronto.

One horse was euthanized on June 10 after becoming recumbent with a fever. A second horse in the same barn (Barn 1) also had a fever and showed neurological signs. The second horse was transported to the Ontario Veterinary College for further evaluation and treatment.

Thoroughbred racing will continue at Woodbine. However, due to the infectious nature of this disease, the ORC has ordered the implementation of various infectious disease protocols to protect our equine athletes.

Effective immediately:

  • In order to determine any further spread of the disease to horses in other barns, no horses are to exit Woodbine Racetrack without ORC approval for the next seven days (June 19). This restriction may be reviewed based on the progression of the disease.
  • In addition, no horse is allowed in or out of Barn 1 or Barn 3 for the next seven days, including training. This restriction may be reviewed, based on the progression of the disease. `
  • All horses stabled at Woodbine must have their temperatures taken and recorded visibly on the horse’s stall door for inspection. Trainers with horses that have clinical signs consistent with EHV-1 infection (including fever (101.5 F/38.5 C or above), respiratory signs (cough, nasal discharge and/or neurological signs) must report these findings to their veterinarian immediately.

Horse people who had horses at Woodbine Racetrack within the last seven days should monitor their horses for any signs of illness.

Standardbred horses are not stabled at Woodbine Racetrack. As well, the standardbred racing meet concluded at Woodbine on May 20, 2013 and moved to Mohawk Raceway on May 23. Therefore theJune 15 North American Cup at Mohawk will not be impacted by these measures.

The neurotrophic form of EHV-1 identified from these horses differs from the non-neurotrophic form identified from the Standardbreds at Campbellville (a harness track also in Ontario) in May of this year.

To ensure best practices are in place to contain the disease, the ORC received input from the office of the Chief Veterinarian for Ontario, Ontario Ministry of Agriculture and Food (OMAF) and also worked closely with Woodbine management, veterinarians and horse people.

The ORC will continue to closely monitor the situation and any further developments will be reported.

Learn more about equine biosecurity with Equine Guelph’s special risk calculator site.



jumping-foal-713469 by Fran Jurga
© The Jurga Report at Equisearch.com 

Be friends with Fran Jurga on Facebook.com  

The Geography of Luck: Federal Protection Act for North Carolina Wild Horses Clears US House of Representatives as Western Herds Seek a New Plan

Corolla mare and foal by DCJohn

You could be a mustang foraging for a tuft of grass on a Nevada desert plateau. Or you could be a Corolla wild horse basking on the beach in North Carolina. Either way, the federal government has a plan for you. (photo: DCJohn)

Where you were born has a lot to do with your future. That is, if you happen to be a wild horse in the United States.

If you think that the United States Congress is in a partisan gridlock that will not allow any legislation to pass, think again.

If you think that the wild horse situation in the United States is in a gridlock equal to that of Congress, check the map first.

An isolated herd of wild horses has been roaming the sands of North Carolina’s Currituck National Wildlife Refuge for about 500 years. The Corolla Wild Horses Protection Act (H.R. 126) passed the U.S. House of Representatives last week and moves on now to the U.S. Senate. The legislation will protect the horses, expand their numbers, and allow expansion of the herd’s gene pool via the introduction of horses from a different coastal herd in North Carolina.

But the legislation pits the concerns of local and private interests against the policies of government agencies. Will the Senate hear the voices or the official policy recommendation?

Perhaps the most newsworthy aspect of the legislation–besides the fact that it was unanimously approved by the House Natural Resources Committee–is that it doesn’t ask the federal government for any money.

Maybe that is partly why it passed so easily.

According to the congressional summary, H.R. 126 directs the Secretary of the Interior to enter into an agreement with the Corolla Wild Horse Fund, a non-profit organization, regarding the management of free-roaming wild horses within and around the Currituck National Wildlife Refuge in North Carolina.  The bill stipulates that the horse population shall be between 110-130 horses and allows for the introduction of a small number of individual horses from Cape Lookout National Seashore in order to maintain the genetic diversity of the Currituck population.  The bill also stipulates that the costs associated with maintaining the herd are to be borne by the Corolla Wild Horse Fund.

The bill was introduced on January 3, 2013 by Representative Walter Jones (R-NC) ; it took exactly six months to advance the legislation to a vote and send it on to the Senate.

Compare the problems of the North Carolina horses, and their support for a form of home rule from Congress, with the plight of a huge population of running-wild and captive-wild horses in the western United States, where the horses are under the jurisdiction of a Bureau of Land Management management plan that was recently denounced as unsustainable in a 600-page wild horse report by the National Research Council.

What’s the difference between horses in North Carolina and horses in Nevada? After all, both are living on federal land, which means that Congress is ultimately in charge of making decisions about their futures. The difference is that mustangs in western states are on lands managed by the Bureau of Land Management (BLM), where they compete with commercial ranchers who want to use the land for their cattle.

The wild horses in North Carolina, on the other hand, are on land managed by the US Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS). The same is true for the famous ponies of Assateague Island, home of Misty of Chincoteague.

If it seems like these two government agencies are operating in separate orbits, consider this: both are agencies within the same cabinet office, the Department of the Interior (DOI).

The BLM is managing the vast population of western horses under the Wild Free-Roaming Horses and Burros Act of 1971. Whether a herd is in Wyoming or New Mexico or California, if it roams on BLM land, it is under BLM management.

And if western wild horses are on non-BLM federal land, what then? Their future can be full of question marks, too. At the Sheldon National Wildlife Refuge in northwestern Nevada, FWS policies have governed the wild horses that roam on the protected land. But the land is protected for its wildlife species, and horses are not considered to be one of those species. In fact, horses are perceived as destructive to the native species and the habitat. As a result, the FWS started “gathering” some of the wild horses on the refuge last year, with a goal of a horse-free refuge by 2017.

How different are things in North Carolina?

YouTube Preview Image

While the wild horses of the western states are descendants of horses that roamed free from settlements, ranches and cavalry posts, the east coast horses in North Carolina have been shown to be a genetic remnant of Spanish horses from colonial times. They have a rich history equal to the western mustangs and they bring in crowds of tourists who want to photograph them in the surf.

But the FWS doesn’t see eye-to-eye with the county government and private citizens who see the horses as an asset to tourism. According to the government website, the FWS official policy regarding Curritack National Wildlife Refuge “considers the horses to be non-native, feral animals and not a natural component of the barrier island ecosystem. These animals compete with native wildlife species for food and fresh water. Their activities degrade and destroy habitat which negatively impacts native species. The Service actively manages critical habitat areas by erecting fences to keep the nuisance animals out and to prevent habitat damage.”

This FWS policy is similar to the policy in Nevada that mandates the FWS as protective of the native species. In government policy on both ends of the country, wild horses are nuisances. The FWS recommendation for a herd size on the Outer Banks was set at 60. The Corolla Wild Horse Fund thinks the land can sustain over 100 and they went to Congress to get the approval to increase the herd.

Will the legislation make it through the Senate and go on to the White House for President Obama’s signature? That is the big question.

The Corolla approach would be a foot in the door for groups other than government agencies to have hands-on jurisdiction over wild horses. Can the Senate be expected to vote for a policy that is not recommended by an agency of the government? How strongly will the FWS oppose the legislation at the Senate level? Will the bill even make it out of committee to the Senate floor?

Representative Jones is optimistic.“The Corolla wild horses are a beautiful piece of Eastern North Carolina heritage that must be protected,” he said on his website.  “Not only does this legislation preserve the history and culture of the Outer Banks, it also protects the local economy that thrives on the tourism money generated by the horses.

“This is the second time in the last two years that my Republican and Democratic colleagues have come together in a bipartisan fashion and passed this bill through the House.  Unfortunately, the Senate took no action on the bill last year.  If both of our North Carolina senators get behind this effort, I am certain that we can get this through the Democrat-controlled Senate and passed into law.”

While the North Carolina wild horse population is tiny compared to the western population, this is a chance for a new form of management, and a chance for the voice of citizens and wild horse advocates to be heard. In fact, it sets a precedent for citizens to become stakeholders in decision-making for wild horse futures in the United States.

Last week, the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (ASPCA) added their support to both the Corolla legislation and the NRC call for a new BLM plan.

Success in the Senate for the Corolla legislation could be a catalyst for change, coast to coast.

Read the Corolla Wild Horse Fund’s evaluation of the Congressional legislation to increase the herd.

Read the text of HR 126, the Corolla Wild Horses Protection Act.



jumping-foal-713469 by Fran Jurga
© The Jurga Report at Equisearch.com 

Be friends with Fran Jurga on Facebook.com