Timing + Clarity = (Almost) Magic!

I’ve had the privilege of working with some extraordinary trainers over the years while creating how-to articles for Horse&Rider. I’m always struck by how, when it comes to the nitty-gritty, they all tend to emphasize the same basic things.

Timing and clarity are two of those things.

Timing is knowing (1) when to give a cue (usually rein or leg or seat pressure) and, even more important, (2) when to cease giving it—thereby rewarding the horse for responding.

Teach your horse Julie Goodnight’s simple drop-head maneuver to discover how nearly magical good timing and cue clarity can be. | Photo © Heidi Nyland Melocco; used with permission

Clarity is making sure the horse knows exactly what you’re asking for in order to get the reward.

I thought of these two qualities the other day when I was marveling at how easy it’s been to teach a “get-your-head-in” cue to every horse I’ve had on my place. You see, my run-in shed has one stall whose window can make feeding grain or pellets difficult. If the horse in that stall has his head poking out that window, I can’t reach in to place the grain in the corner feeder. And of course when you’re coming at a horse with goodies, he’s keen to meet you halfway, so out pops the head.

But, as I say, the solution has been surprisingly easy. Using clarity and timing, I’ve been able to teach every horse that’s used that stall (so far: two Quarter Horses, a Paint, a Pinto/Arabian, my daughter’s Arabian/Mustang, and a friend’s warmblood) to pull its head back from the window so I can reach the feeder.

I did it simply by standing there, grain in hand, and saying “get-your-head-in” in an authoritative voice, over and over, until by chance the horse withdrew its head into the stall, at which point I’d immediately dump the grain into the feeder. From the get-go, it was clear to each horse what had to be done (withdraw head), and the perfectly timed reward (grain in feeder) reinforced the correct behavior.

As a result, all of the horses had this command down pat by the second day’s lesson. Like magic!

Static situations like this one are relatively easy, however. Maintaining both clarity and timing while you’re riding along on your horse’s back is a much greater challenge. Often the key to success there is breaking things down. In other words, you teach just one thing at a time, rather than shooting for softness in the bridle, lateral flexion through the topline, and the proper bend on a circle all at once.

Ask for just one of these qualities, then add the next, then the next, always allowing the time it takes for your horse to “get” each new bit of learning.

And, if your horse seems confused at any point, stop and make sure your cueing for whatever maneuver you’re asking for is both correct and clear. (Ask a pro for help if you’re uncertain.) Then, too, be sure you’re providing the reward (release of pressure) at the exact moment your horse gives a little “try.” If your timing is off, you’ll be inadvertently rewarding the wrong thing, which means you’re programming bad info into your horse’s “onboard computer.” Not good!

I know from my own experience that all this is easier to explain than it is to do. Getting really good at it, though, is worth the effort, as it will make you into a much better rider and trainer.

If you want to see first hand how nearly magical good timing and clarity can be, try this. Go out to your barn and teach your horse the drop-head cue as described by clinician Julie Goodnight. The cue for this is perfectly clear (gentle downward pressure on the halter), and if your timing is also perfect (you “give” the instant your horse’s head moves minutely downward), your horse will learn this maneuver quickly–almost like magic.

Or try teaching the drop-head cue from the saddle, using our online video from Julie.

Once you fully appreciate how powerful timing and clarity can be, you can begin to apply them more effectively to everything you teach to your horse.

The results will be, well, like magic!

When ‘Don’t Wanna’ Means ‘Ouch’

When a ride goes well, all is good. But when your horse becomes suddenly resistant under saddle, rule out a physical cause first. | H&R photo by Alana Harrison

When your horse balks at something you’ve asked him to do—perhaps a maneuver he knows well, or something new you’re trying to teach him—do you automatically insist? Or do you stop and think, realizing his resistance can be a signal? Thoughtful riders generally don’t insist on compliance from a reluctant horse until they’ve eliminated certain other possible causes for that reluctance.

Such as physical discomfort or pain. I remember how frustrated I was years ago when a Quarter Horse gelding I owned at the time refused to bend on a circle—especially going to the right. Bending had never been his favorite thing, but I’d been making progress with him in that regard. Then suddenly he was backsliding. Or so I thought.

In reality, he had a right-foot issue that was prompting him to avoid bending right to keep from putting any extra pressure on that foot. Once that slight bruise was healed, his “unwillingness” and the resulting “training issue” cleared right up.

Another time, more recently, my daughter’s Arabian/mustang-cross gelding, Brego, began not wanting to round through his topline. Whenever I’d ride him, I couldn’t figure out why he was being such a pill about flexing vertically through his back and reaching up underneath himself with his hind legs.

Again, I felt frustrated…and now I wish so much I could go back in time and undo the insistence I used to try to get him as round as I just “knew” he could be.

Turns out he was in the early stages of EPM—equine protozoal myeloencephalitis–a microscopic-bug infection of the central nervous system. No wonder he didn’t want to bend his spine! I wish my first thought back then had been, “This horse is normally so willing–something must be wrong. Let’s find out what it is.”

Instead of, “Horse, behave.”

Horse & Rider’s consulting editor, Barb Crabbe, DVM, is adamant on this issue. As she points out, “Shoulder pain, stifle pain, foot pain–any of these can make a horse reluctant to work and resistant to bending, especially. If you suspect a physical problem, check in with your vet before resuming work.”

She adds that horses sometimes just have bad days, too, especially if they’re a little muscle sore.

Knowing this and always acting accordingly are two different things, however—even for an upper-level dressage rider who’s also a vet.

As Dr. Barb explains, drawing from her own example: “I’d been on vacation and my mare had been on pasture turnout for two weeks. Then, on the day after my first really solid ride on her, I got grumpy because she was being really resistant in the rein back. I didn’t let it go–and I wish I had.

“The worst part,” she goes on, “is that I’d even planned on just doing an easy/stretchy ride that day because I figured she might be a little sore.

Barb Crabbe, DVM, in competition. | Courtesy of B. Crabbe

I know I sometimes get sore from the gym or pilates, so why wouldn’t horses? Once I was riding, however, my assertiveness kicked in. Stupid. I apologized to her the next day, and fortunately for me, she’s a forgiving type.”

Dr. Barb’s bottom line? “It’s essential for us as riders always to consider possible physical causes for resistance—then follow through accordingly.”

Easy to say, harder to do, but always worth striving for.

NOTE: For details on physical conditions that can affect your horse’s behavior, see Dr. Barb’s popular book, The Comprehensive Guide to Equine Veterinary Medicine.

Predator Is As Predator Does

Image courtesy of Wikigallery.org

This image always grabs me, and no pun intended. George Stubbs is my all-time favorite painter of horses, but this particular painting is hard to look at, for obvious reasons. It does bring the concept of predator into sharp focus, though, doesn’t it? It’s also a perfect lead-in to what I’d like to talk about, and that’s the difference between being a predator and acting like one.

I’ve written before about how important it is not to behave in ways that cause your horse to regard you as a predator (“Are You Stalking Your Horse?”). Now, something I read in a book by Robert M. Miller, DVM, over the weekend has clarified this whole concept for me.

You see, it’s always been hard for me to imagine any of my horses regarding me as a predator, no matter how I behave. My horses know me. They know how I look and how I smell and the sound of my voice. I’m the person who feeds them and grooms them and scratches their itchy spots. How could they ever view me as a predator?

The answer is, they don’t need to. As Dr. Miller makes clear in Natural Horsemanship Explained, “Horses are not afraid of predators. They’re afraid of predatory behavior.”

To support this premise, Miller points out that horses can be persuaded to work with tamed tigers in circus acts—even to the extent of allowing the tigers to ride on their backs. (The lion is behaving like a rider, not a predator.) Zebras aren’t alarmed by the sight of a pride of lions in repose; they react only when the lions arise and take on a predatory posture, and thereby become menacing.

Most horses aren’t automatically afraid of dogs, but if a border collie assumes a stalking pose and fixes its gaze on a horse, the horse will notice and react.

So, think about this when you’re working with and riding your horse. If your goal is to form the closest bond with him you possibly can, you’ll want to be very mindful of how you behave and the signals you send.

You want to be your horse’s respected leader—not something that even vaguely brings to mind Stubbs’ lion.

Cowlicks: Cues to Temperament?

Whorls, or cowlicks, form in the fetus at the same time as the nervous system. Many believe a single whorl roughly centered on the forehead, as on this stallion, tends to be linked to an uncomplicated nature. | © Caroline Fyffe

That whorl or cowlick on your horse’s face—does it indicate his inborn temperament? Can whorl placement even help you predict the behavior tendencies of a prospect you’re thinking of buying?

Many would say yes.

I’ve been fascinated by whorls ever since doing the research for an article I wrote a few years ago. “What’s in a Whorl?” tells about the science behind these hair swirls (courtesy of Temple Grandin, PhD, and others). It also shares what horsemen like Bob Avila, Benny Guitron, and Doug Carpenter think of whorls.

For those who do believe, the basic premise is this: A whorl centered on the forehead at the level of the eyes or slightly below tends to indicate a less reactive temperament—in other words, a horse that may be easier overall to work with.

A whorl higher up on the forehead, or two or more spaced somewhat apart, may indicate a more complicated nature. (To see a basic diagram of forehead-whorl placement plus one horseman’s take on whorl analysis, click here.)

Why the link between whorls and temperament? Scientists speculate it’s because the nervous system (which involves temperament) and the skin (which contains the whorl patterns) are formed in the same embryonic layer during a foal’s development in the womb.

Still, both Temple Grandin and Linda Tellington-Jones (whose book first popularized the analysis of whorls) stress that these markers are best used not as a way to rank horses but as a guide in training.

“I’m not a fan of rough training methods in general, but if you use them on a high-whorl individual, you’ll probably traumatize and wreck that animal,” Grandin says, adding that you should be careful to avoid even mildly frightening a horse with high whorls.

For more on whorls, check out this Polish hair-swirl study and review my original article. Then go out and examine the cowlicks on your own horses and let us know: Are you a believer? Do whorls seem to be a reflection of your horses’ basic temperament?

Yeah, But, MY Horse…

The urge to make excuses for a naughty horse is a terrible substitute for proper training. | © bonnietimmons.com

Do you ever make excuses for your horse’s misbehavior? We asked this question in Horse & Rider awhile back and bagged some interesting replies.

“But he’s a stud,” was one excuse for a stallion with poor manners.

And, “She’s too much of a lady to get her feet wet,” for a mare who balked at water crossings.

And, “It’s raining, and everyone’s grumpy on a rainy day,” for an ill-tempered gelding.

These kinds of excuses are everywhere, really. In his recently re-released classic, Training on the Trail, Clinton Anderson shares a few of the excuses he’s heard his students use.

Such as, “I can’t ride with her because my horse doesn’t like her horse.”

And, “I couldn’t go on that trail ride because my horse won’t cross ditches.”

And, “I can’t leave my horse tied because he gets lonely.”

Clinton says we use these ridiculous alibis because our horses teach us to.

“Horses are phenomenal ‘people trainers,’” he says. As a result, we wind up trying to explain away the things they’ve trained us to let them do—or refuse to do.

The urge to cover over these little weak spots in our horse’s training is strong because the alternative means work. When we admit our horse’s failings and take responsibility for them, we must then set about fixing them.

And we should, because insisting on good behavior sends an important signal to a horse. As Clinton explains, “Your horse is constantly reading you in an effort to determine, ‘Is she serious, or not?’ He’ll test you in small ways—push into your space, wait a heartbeat before responding to your request, attempt to ‘get an inch’ here and there.”

Then your horse observes how you respond. If you gloss over these small cheats, he’ll eventually pull a much larger one.

“At that point,” the trainer adds, “you may feel he’s acting out of the blue. But, in reality, he’s been telling you for some time, via those little cheats, that he’s losing respect for you.

“But you haven’t been ‘listening’–or correcting him.”

So, for your benefit and his—no excuses!

(For training books by Clinton Anderson and other experts, search at HorseBooksEtc.)